LLCs and Diversity Jurisdiction

Friday, January 22, 2010 by Transportation Lawyer
 When litigation arises, motor carriers, brokers, freight forwarders, and other transportation companies are often faced with the issue of whether to remove a state court case to federal court.  Removal is permitted if the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000 and "complete diversity" among all parties exists, i.e. no party to the litigation has the same citizenship as any party on the other side.  What affect does a motor carrier's status as an LLC have on diversity of citizenship? Quite a bit.  While the citizenship of a corporation is determined by the place of incorporation, the citizenship of LLCs is that of their members.  Consequently, an Ohio logistics company formed as a limited liability company whose members are citizens of three different states takes on the citizenship of all three states, regardless of whether work is done in those other states.  Taking it one step further, if the Ohio LLC's members are LLCs too, citizenship is traced through multiple levels, meaning each LLCs' members must be accounted for in determining diversity, which ultimately could immunize an LLC from being hauled into federal court.  Whether you are the suing party or the one being sued, understanding the nuisances of federal procedure will reduce costs associated with either filing the Complaint or seeking removal. 

Comments for LLCs and Diversity Jurisdiction

Leave a comment





Captcha