On April 25, 2012, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) issued important new guidance impacting the way employers use criminal arrest and conviction records of prospective employees to make hiring decisions. Motor carriers (including last-mile carriers, household goods carriers, and couriers) dealing directly with homeowners, residents, and retail consumers are quite often required by their retailer customers to perform criminal background checks. Although the EEOC’s guidance applies to “employers” as opposed to contractors of owner/operators, caution and attention are warranted. Employers seeking to avoid liability for claims of discrimination under the disparate impact and disparate treatment prohibitions contained in Title VII are advised to evaluate their application and hiring policies to ensure compliance with the EEOC’s new guidance.
Under the EEOC’s new guidance, an employer’s (e.g. motor carrier) blanket policy or practice of excluding applicants with criminal records from employment may violate Title VII to the extent the policy strays far from Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations and the commercial motor vehicle driver disqualifications listed at 49 U.S.C. § 31310. Instead, the EEOC now requires narrowly-tailored individualized assessments, or “targeted screens,” of applicants that consider the nature of the crime, the time elapsed since the arrest or conviction, and the specific responsibilities of the job for which the applicant is applying.
With the new guidance in place, employers should expect the EEOC to step up its investigative and enforcement efforts, particularly to the extent blanket criminal background policies raise the “pattern or practice” flags most noticeable to the EEOC. Motor carriers that “employ” drivers and helpers to conduct in-home deliveries should therefore evaluate their application and hiring policies related to the use of criminal arrest and conviction records to ensure narrow tailoring and individualized assessments in light of the new EEOC guidance. Even contractor-model motor carriers should use reasonable efforts to avoid overly-broad screening of owner/operators. For additional information on the new EEOC guidance, or to discuss implementing a policy that minimizes your company’s exposure on a claim of discrimination in its hiring practices, contact Greg Feary, Jim Hanson, David Robinson, or Jack Finklea in the Firm’s Indianapolis office at (317) 637-1777.